One line is under pressure and the other is not
The water line from the meter to the house is pressurized all day and all night. If it has a hole, water comes out of that hole whether anyone in the house is using water or not.
The sewer line, or the drain line on a septic house, carries nothing until something drains. It runs on gravity. A crack in it only leaks when a toilet flushes, a shower runs or the washing machine empties.
Every sign that follows comes back to that one difference. A water line leak is constant. A sewer leak comes and goes with the household.
Run the meter test first
Turn off every fixture and appliance that uses water. Check the ice maker, the water softener and the irrigation timer, because all three run on their own and will spoil the test.
Find the meter, usually in a box near the street. Look at the leak indicator, the small triangle or star dial on the face. If it is turning with everything off, water is going somewhere. If it is still, write down the full reading and check again in an hour.
If the meter moved, close the main shutoff where the line enters the house and watch the meter again. Still moving means the leak is between the meter and the house, which is the yard. Stopped means the leak is inside the house.
A meter that sits completely still with everything off points away from the water line. The supply side is holding. If the yard is still wet, the sewer line, the irrigation or the septic system moves up the list.
The water line leaks whether you use water or not. The sewer line only leaks when you do.
What the wet spot tells you
Water from a supply line is clean, so the ground is wet with clear water and the soil goes soft. It stays wet overnight, through a dry week and while the family is away. It has no smell.
A sewer leak smells. It is wettest after the morning showers or a load of laundry and drier after a night with nothing draining. The water is gray or dark, and in a bad case you will see paper. It also shows up along the route the line takes from the house to the street or the septic tank, often over a cleanout or a joint.
Grass over a line that is greener and taller than the lawn around it means the line is putting something into the soil. Over a water line that is just steady water, and the patch is usually round and soggy. Over a sewer line it is water and fertilizer, and the patch tends to follow the pipe as a strip that grows faster than anything else in the yard.
To check a suspected sewer leak, put dye tablets or a strong food coloring in a toilet and flush it a few times. If the color turns up in the wet spot, that is the drain line.
What the rest of the house tells you
A water line leak takes water away from the fixtures. A large one shows up as weak pressure at every tap and shower at once. A small one may not change the pressure at all, which is why the meter is the better test.
The water bill climbs with a supply leak, because every gallon that leaks goes through the meter first. A sewer leak does not move the water bill, because the water was already used and paid for before it went down the drain.
A sewer problem shows up as slow drains, toilets that gurgle when a tub empties, or the lowest drain in the house backing up when the washer runs. Pressure stays normal. If you have good pressure, slow drains and a wet yard, look at the sewer line.
Why the two get found with different equipment
A pressurized leak makes noise. Water forced out of a hole under pressure creates a sound in the pipe and the soil, and acoustic listening equipment picks it up from the surface. A pressure test confirms the line is losing water, and tracer gas finds the spot when the sound is too faint.
A drain line makes no noise worth listening to, because there is no pressure behind the water. It gets found from the inside. A camera goes in through a cleanout and shows the cracked joint, the roots or the broken section, with a counter for how far down the line it is. A transmitter on the camera head lets a locator on the surface mark the exact spot and depth.
This is why it helps to know which one you have before you call. The meter result, the smell, and whether the drains are slow tell us which equipment to bring. Neither set of tools finds the other kind of fault.
We are a plumbing contractor. We locate and repair the water line and the sewer or drain line. If the trouble turns out to be in the septic tank or drainfield itself, that work belongs to a septic contractor, and we will tell you so.
