How each one goes into a house
PEX is flexible plastic tubing that comes on a roll. It gets pulled through the attic and fished down inside the walls in long continuous lengths, and it bends around corners instead of needing a fitting at each one. Fewer fittings means fewer joints, and a joint is where most supply plumbing fails.
Copper is rigid pipe in straight lengths. Every change of direction is a fitting, and every fitting is a joint that has to be soldered with a torch or pressed with a press tool. The joints are reliable when they are made properly. There are simply a lot more of them.
PEX goes in one of two layouts. Home-run means a manifold near the water heater with a separate line to each fixture, each with its own shutoff. Trunk-and-branch looks like a copper system: a larger main line with tees splitting off to each room. Home-run uses more tubing and fewer hidden fittings. Trunk-and-branch uses less tubing and puts more joints inside the walls. Plenty of houses get a mix of the two.
The PEX connection matters as much as the tubing. Crimp and clamp fittings squeeze a metal ring over the tubing onto a barbed fitting. Expansion fittings stretch the tubing over the fitting and let it shrink back down, and the opening through the fitting stays closer to the full bore of the pipe. Both are code-approved. Each only works with the tubing types and tools it was made for.
What each one means for your drywall
This is the difference most homeowners feel. PEX can be snaked from the attic down a wall cavity to a fixture through one opening at the top and one at the fixture. Copper needs room to cut, fit and join at every turn, so the openings are usually bigger and there are more of them.
Soldering inside a finished wall means an open flame next to framing, insulation and old dust. Good plumbers shield it and watch it. Press-fit copper avoids the flame entirely and needs less room to work, which narrows the drywall gap between the two materials without closing it.
Neither one gets done without cutting drywall. Any contractor telling you otherwise has not looked at your house. What changes is how many holes and how large, and that depends on the layout and the attic as much as on the pipe.
What a hot, humid Florida house does to each one
Water first. Copper does not like aggressive water. Acidic well water, water treated with chloramine, and hot water moving fast through a recirculating loop can all eat the pipe from the inside and end in pinhole leaks that keep coming back. Plenty of houses out here are on private wells. PEX does not corrode, and scale from hard water does not grip its walls the way it builds up in copper. The brass fittings on a PEX system can still be attacked by aggressive water, which is why the fitting material gets chosen for the water as well.
Sunlight. PEX breaks down under UV. Manufacturers limit how long the tubing can sit in sunlight, and the limit is short. A shaded attic is fine. A run near a gable vent, a ridge vent, a skylight or any exterior wall has to be covered, sleeved or rerouted. Copper does not care about the sun.
Sweating and heat. A cold line through a humid attic sweats, and copper sweats more because it carries the cold to its surface. The drips stain ceilings and feed mold. PEX sweats less but is not immune. Attics here also get hot enough to warm the cold line until the first minute out of the tap runs warm. Both materials should be insulated through the attic. That is a workmanship question, not a material one.
Rodents and abrasion. Roof rats and squirrels in a Florida attic will chew PEX. They leave copper alone. PEX also needs protecting where it passes through framing and anywhere it can rub, so it is not slowly worn through by its own movement. Copper needs nail plates in the walls too, but it does not wear through against a stud. If there is a rodent history in the attic, that goes into the decision.
The water coming into the house decides more about copper's lifespan than the copper does.
Noise, water hammer and how long each one lasts
Copper carries sound. Water rushing through it, a valve snapping shut, the pipe expanding against a strap as hot water runs, can all be heard through a wall. When a washing machine or a quick-closing faucet shuts off and the pipe bangs, copper transmits it. PEX flexes and soaks up much of that shock, so a PEX house is usually quieter. Water hammer still needs fixing at the cause, whatever the pipe.
Service life is a range, not a promise. Copper in water that suits it is commonly expected to last fifty years or more, and many copper systems outlive the house they went into. Copper in aggressive water can start pinholing far sooner. PEX manufacturers commonly rate their tubing for around forty to fifty years. PEX has been in American houses for less time than copper, so fewer people have watched a full lifetime of it.
Neither range tells you anything about one particular house. We will tell you what each material is typically rated for. We will not tell you how many years your new pipe will give you, because that depends on water and workmanship nobody can measure in advance.
What we look at before recommending one
The water. City or well, and if it is a well, what a water test says about acidity and hardness. If the old copper in the house pinholed, the pattern of those leaks tells us a lot about what the water does to metal. The attic. How much of the run can stay shaded, how hot it gets, what the access is like, and whether there are signs of rodents. The layout. How many fixtures, one story or two, and what is above the ceilings that a run would have to cross.
Then the joints. More repipes fail at a bad fitting than in the pipe itself. A crimp ring that went on crooked or was never checked with a gauge, an expansion ring stretched too little, a solder joint that was not cleaned or fluxed properly, a burr left inside a cut pipe that erodes the wall downstream. Copper lines held with the wrong metal straps can corrode where the two metals touch. Any of those fails on either material, and a well-made joint on either one lasts.
One thing that is not ours to decide. In some houses the metal water pipe is part of the electrical bonding path. Replacing it with plastic can change that, and whether the electrical system needs work afterward is a question for a licensed electrician. Pipe Perfect LLC is a Florida Certified Plumbing Contractor, license CFC1431903, and a repipe is permitted and inspected under that license. We do not perform or sign electrical work, home inspections, four-point inspections, or anything else requiring a license we do not hold.
We will not name a number for either material before walking the house. The fixture count, the attic and the layout decide it, and those have to be seen.
